Tuesday, April 16, 2013

An Exakta to Canon EOS Adapter that Allows Infinity Focus

I feel weird to write about an adapter that has no name, because if you want to buy one, I can't tell you want brand it is. But this one looks very different than most other EXA to EOS adapters. Do a search on eBay and you should find one. Mine cost $18USD with free shipping from Hong Kong.

I had two Exakta to EOS adapters which I bought few years ago, and both of them could not make the lenses focus to infinity, despite what the seller claimed. I decided to give it another try when I saw an ultra-thin adapter, which arrived very promptly from Hong Kong few days ago after I bought it from eBay. Few of of my Exakta mount lenses have shutter button arm on the lens and the arm prevents the lens from mounting flat on the adapter. Some lenses with longer arms, like the Topcor 10cm f2.8 and the 5.8cm f1.8, can not be mounted on the Canon DSLRs at all. What a pity. For those with shorter arms, like the Pancolar 50mm f2 and the Flegtogon 35mm f2.8, I had to file the raised portion on the arm to mount the lens on the adapter; see picture #3.

It turns out that the new adapter can in fact focus the lenses to infinity, but at a cost. It's very thin and mounts more towards the mirror box than other EXA-EOS adapters, and on the 5D Mark II, it catches the mirror and you can't use it with the optical view finder. I must un-mount the lens/adapter, turn on live-view, flip up the mirror and then mount the lens/adapter. When the mirror is disengaged, it will just rest on the rear of the adapter and that should be OK. Whenever I need to take pictures, I will need to flip the mirror up and use it like a mirrorless camera without a viewfinder.

The new adapter mounts VERY tightly to the lens. Because it's so thin, you can't mount it without using a rag or towel to cushion the edge, so that it won't cut you as you apply force. Unlike most adapters, the locking mechanism is not spring loaded. This means you have to keep an eye on the locking pin as you mount the lens and when the locking pin on the lens is at the center of the notch on the locking mechanism of the adapter, you have to push it down to lock it; see picture #4 below. To un-mount the lens, you would have to manually flip up the locking mechanism to unlock, and then un-mount the lens.

Here is the good news if you don't use a 5D/5D II. This adapter works with my 20D (1.6x), and 1D Mark III (1.3x). The mirror on these two cameras did not hit the lens/adapter even at infinity focus. I would assume all crop-sensor Canon are OK, and possibly the 1Ds series of full frame bodies are also fine. So, perhaps, only the 5D/5D II (don't know about the 5D III) have problems. Also, the adapter is quite precise. If you set the lens to infinity, it's in focus. This means you don't have to check focus if you are going take pictures far away; just set the lens to infinity and you know it will be in focus.

New adapter on left, old adapter on right. Notice the old (silver) one is larger, which is not good as it will interfere more with the arm on the lens.

Thickness test - new one is 0.68mm, old one is 1.04mm. Anything thicker than 0.7mm will not attain infinity focus.

The raised portion on the arm has to be filed flat in order for the adapter to mount flush.

Mounted - Note the manual locking/unlocking mechanism.

9 comments:

  1. Can you say us the name of the ebay seller?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Replies
    1. Here is the listing:
      http://www.ebay.ca/itm/130827028220?ssPageName=STRK:MEWNX:IT&_trksid=p3984.m1439.l2649#ht_1022wt_1397

      Delete
  3. Is it worth the effort of sanding down? I have the Carl Zeiss Tessar 2.8 / 50, and want to fit it to my Canon Eos 500 (film)

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hello Mr Yu-Lin Chan

    I also tested the 1.04mm adapter with EOS 6D and could uneventfully use CZ Tessar 2.8/80 without the mirror hitting problem. But i also found when using Primotar 3.5/80 that there still exists another risk, i.e., the mirror hits the claw of lens.

    Thus, we have to be careful not to encounter this problem even if we use 1.04mm adapter to the lens with long focal length.

    spiral

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I withdrew the above my opinion. I tested again and could uneventfully use Primotar 3.5/80 at that time. Maybe, the mirror was hitting the fixing bracket of the mount adapter, which was a little distorted by some unknown reason.

      Delete
  5. Thanks for review, it was excellent and very informative.
    thank you :)

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hello Mr Yu-Lin Chan.
    I own a Canon EOS 60D and some old Exakta-mount lenses (Kilfitt Macro-Kilar 40 f/2,8, Zeiss Auto Sonnar 135 f/4, Kilfitt Tele-Kilar 300 f/5,6), so I just bought the adapter you suggested.
    To be able to mount the adapter on each lens I needed to file (very, very careful, with wet waterproof sandpaper 600) its Exakta flange.
    In this way the thickness has been slightly reduced (I cannot measure the difference with a caliper) and the lenses can be mounted with some friction.
    I hope this experience can be useful.
    Bye!

    ReplyDelete
  7. i'm just encountering this problem now with fotodiox's premium exakta to eos adapter. i will simply stick with my thicker fotasy adapter for now.

    ReplyDelete